The Church of God (Cleveland) is a Protestant/Pentecostal Christian denomination whose headquarters are in Cleveland, Tennessee. The movement's origins can be traced back to 1886 with a small meeting of Christians at the Barney Creek Meeting House on the Tennessee/North Carolina border. It has grown to become one of the largest Holiness Pentecostal denominations in the world.
Because of Spurling's and Bryant's resistance to the creation of creeds and church polity, however, this young fellowship of Christians remained ungoverned by any clear, specific doctrinal standards, and so soon fell into a degree of reproach and decline due the outlandish behaviors and incredible beliefs of some of the initial adherents. It was not until the coming of A.J. Tomlinson in 1903 that the needed degree of organization, discipline, and vision were injected into the small church.
A. J. Tomlinson, a former Quaker, united with the church at Camp Creek in 1903, after climbing what is now known as "Prayer Mountain" (located in the Fields of the Wood park that is run by the COGOP in Murphy, NC) and being divinely assured that this fledgling church was indeed God's reestablishment of the New Testament church upon earth. Tomlinson was selected to pastor the congregation, and his drive and vision brought about efforts that resulted in other churches being organized in Georgia, North Carolina, and Tennessee. The first General Assembly was held in 1906, and though the intention was still to avoid the creation of a creed and denomination, the members' consensus on certain endeavors and standards laid the groundwork for a future denomination, and perhaps soon demonstrated to the adherents the benefit of some degree of standardization of doctrine, etc.
The name Church of God was adopted in 1907. In 1909 Tomlinson was elected General Overseer. The Church of God was known as a "holiness" church rather than a Pentecostal one during these early years, though some had experienced the "Pentecostal Blessing" of being baptized in the Holy Ghost. In fact, Tomlinson himself did not receive the baptism of the Holy Ghost until some time later, when the church had moved to Cleveland, TN, and a powerful revival was held by the church. At that revival, the guest speaker had visited the Asuza Street revival and Tomlinson finally experienced this signature blessing. Thereafter, the Church of God began to place additional emphasis on the Pentecostal aspect of the church. Eventually, the Pentecostal emphasis became more predominant than the holiness emphasis, though this latter emphasis is still very much a part of the denomination's beliefs and values.
In 1923, Tomlinson was impeached, causing a division which led to the creation of the Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee) and the Church of God of Prophecy. The impeachment was the result of lax financial bookkeeping on Tomlinson's part, and not due to intentional malfeasance. It appears that in order to support struggling pastors and churches, he had, on occasion, borrowed money from otherwise-designated funds, causing shortfalls. By all accounts, he had never used the funds for his own benefit.
When his handling of finances was called into question, it appears that Tomlinson took some offense at the implications for his integrity, or perhaps to having his long-term and substantial authority questioned. In any case, in retrospect, his critics may have had a motive beside the ensuring of financial integrity. It may be the case that the financial issues were used as an attempt to move the church to a more democratic footing, with the office of General Overseer becoming an elective and termed office, instead of, as then existed, an office where Tomlinson served by general acclaim of the church-at-large. In any case, it appears that Tomlinson's critics felt he had been in power long enough, and took the opportunity to press the matter to the point of division.
Both sides of the controversy now tend to admit missteps by either side: by Tomlinson in taking too much umbrage at the questioning; and by those who questioned him for perhaps having more in mind than simple financial probity, and thus not addressing the matter in a way that would have been more conducive to reconciliation.
The practice of snake handling became a controversy in the denomination in the 1920s after it was endorsed by George W. Hensley, a Church of God minister. The practice was quickly repudiated by the Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee), and Hensley and the small number of congregations which practiced it left to become independent congregations generally using the name Church of God with Signs Following.
The definitive history of the Church of God can be found in Like a Mighty Army, written by Charles W. Conn, Lit.D.(1920-). This is recognized as the essential history of the movement. See also Michael Crews' The Church of God: A Social History (University of Tennessee Press,1990). Visit the Dixon Pentecostal Research Center for more historical resources (*
Presently, there is an on-going effort to work closely with the Church of God of Prophecy (created by the division in 1923). Both churches hold very similar doctrine, and there has been much more cooperation between the churches and leadership.
This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License.
It uses material from the
"Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee)".
Home Page • arts • business • computers • games • health • hospitals • home • kids & teens • news • physicians • recreation• reference • regional • science • shopping • society • sports • world